


Mix in 1/2 cup Key Lime juice-and taste, I added about a tablespoon more juice for a tarter taste. Mix the Cool Whip and sweetened condensed milk (note: NOT evaporated milk) together. 1 graham cracker pie crust-prepared or homemade.A note: if you can’t find the small yellowish Key Limes in your grocery store, you could look for bottles of Key Lime juice like Joe and Nellie’s, or substitute the larger, easier to find Persian limes. It’s quite different from the usual recipe, with the finished product resembling an ice cream pie, but I guarantee, this tart and creamy dessert will make you forget those other pies. Diana was kind enough to share the recipe with us. MKA and I stayed at his favorite mom-and-pop motel on Marathon, in the Florida Keys, where Diana, the owner of The Ranch House Motel, served us this fabulous Key Lime Pie made with juice from her own lime trees, in exchange for some of Mr.
